Monday, November 16, 2026

Game of the Week: McDevitt’s Cayden McDonnell and RJ Duffy Climb Medals Stand in PIAA Diving and Swimming

Popping up from underneath the water at Bucknell University’s Kinney Natatorium, Cayden McDonnell’s expression changed from one of dogged determination to that of satisfaction after securing a fourth-place finish in the PIAA Boys’ AA Diving Championships on March 13.

Heading into the finals, the Bishop McDevitt High School junior was a seventh seed in the 24-diver competition and had set a goal of finishing in the top five in the championships.

McDonnell delivered. Consistently in the top five throughout the competition, he nailed his final dive – a one and a half somersault with two twists – to secure fourth place with an overall score of 410 points, just one shy of his personal best.

“Coming into states, I had set a goal for myself to place in the top five, so I’m very happy to have achieved that goal,” a smiling McDonnell told The Witness alongside the pool, where he placed eighth in the state a year ago.

“I’ve competed here before, but I was still a little nervous coming in here today because I didn’t know about the rest of the competition and how good they are. But I’m happy with my season. Today was also one point under my personal best, so it was a great day,” he said.

McDonnell’s performance was 4.75 points shy of third place, a narrow gap in the finals, won by Caleb Arnot of Interboro with 518.75 points.

The climb from last year’s eighth-place finish to a spot on the medals stand was not lost on McDonnell.

“I can’t wait to get back here next year and work on beating this year’s result,” he said.

“It’s wonderful to be part of the team,” he said of the Crusaders. “Everyone is so supportive at all of our meets. The swimming coaches were here today to cheer me on, along with Marina,” he said, referencing teammate Marina Eshelman, who placed 18th in girls’ diving. “I knew I had everyone’s support, and that makes it part of a great season, too.”

With the divers clearing their end of the pool, it was time for night number two of the Girls’ and Boys’ AA competition. And for the second night in a row, Bishop McDevitt’s boys’ swimmers would again find themselves with state medals.

Junior RJ Duffy added to this year’s haul on Thursday night, one day after a seventh-place finish in the 200 IM and joining teammates Omar Lara, Ian Shyk and Bradley Warner in a fifth-place performance in the 200 free relay.

Putting the cap on his season in the pool, Duffy on the second night swam to a sixth-place finish in the 100 breaststroke before joining teammates Lara, Shyk and Bradley in a tenth-place swim in the 400 relay at the end of the night.

“We definitely have big shoes to fill coming in after the Hancocks, John Haskins, Rocco Solimeo,” Duffy said of joining his relay teammates on the medals stand. “But we knew we could carry their success forward, and it’s just a matter of time until we’re back up there again, so on to next year!”

By all accounts, it was a successful two days for Duffy.

“I just want to thank God and all the opportunities I have had to be able to get here,” Duffy told The Witness at the conclusion of competition March 13.

“The atmosphere here is amazing. It’s just unmatched to anything else. I’d rank swimming above any other sport,” said Duffy, who is also a member of the football and lacrosse teams at Bishop McDevitt. “The environment is so much fun, the people are amazing, the coaches are beyond words. It’s a supportive environment to be in and it helps everyone develop so well.”

Swimmers from Lancaster Catholic, York Catholic and Trinity also placed in the top 16 in AA competition.

Addie Elliott, a senior at Lancaster Catholic, capped off an incredible high school career with a fourth-place finish in the 100 breast stroke on Thursday, after swimming to ninth in the 100 butterfly the night before. She now owns four state medals and four District 3 titles.

York Catholic’s Sarah Giesselbach placed 15th and 16th in the 200 IM and the 500 freestyle, respectively, while Trinity’s Timmy Garber finished 14th in the 200 IM and Josiah Garber placed 15th in the 50 free.

(Photos and video by Jen Reed, The Catholic Witness.)

By Jen Reed, The Catholic Witness

- Advertisement -spot_img

Submission Deadline

The deadline for submissions to the biweekly Notebook/Parish Obituaries listing is every other Wednesday at 4:30 p.m. Please refer to the Publication Schedule for edition dates and deadlines.

Other News